12  Project Solution: Motion Sickness Incidence on Board

Learning Objectives

After reading this chapter, you should be able to:

  • Solve the equations of motion of a ship from panel-method results, add a viscous roll damping, and recognise the numerical artefacts of the data
  • Carry the motions through to the vertical acceleration of a cabin, its spectrum in irregular seas and the motion sickness incidence, avoiding the common mistakes at each step
  • Explain how the type of ship, the speed, the heading, the length of the hull, the position of the cabin and the roll damping each change the MSI

12.1 Motivation

This chapter solves the project of Chapter 11 in two parts. The first works through the calculation in four steps, each with the one mistake that is most often made at that step. The second asks one question at a time: what does each parameter of the problem do to the MSI? Every step and every question comes with a small interactive tool. Play with the tool first, then read the key point below it.

12.2 Step 1: The Motions of the Ship

The RAOs follow from the \(6 \times 6\) equations of motion of Chapter 8, with the added mass, damping and wave loads computed by HydRA and a viscous damping \(\boldsymbol{B}_v\) that we add ourselves:

\[\begin{align} \left[-\omega_e^2\left(\boldsymbol{M} + \boldsymbol{A}(\omega_e)\right) + i\omega_e\left(\boldsymbol{B}(\omega_e) + \boldsymbol{B}_v\right) + \boldsymbol{C}\right]\{\hat{\xi}\} = \{\hat{F}\} \end{align}\]

With \(\boldsymbol{B}_v = 0\), the solution at the computed frequencies must reproduce HydRA’s RAOs. It does, to a relative accuracy better than \(10^{-13}\) for every hull, heading and speed: this is the first check of any code. The only non-zero element of \(\boldsymbol{B}_v\) is the viscous roll damping \(B_{v,44} = \zeta_v\,2\sqrt{C_{44}(M_{44} + A_{44}(\omega_n))}\) with \(\zeta_v = 0.05\). A panel method finds only the damping of the waves radiated by the hull, which for roll is far below \(1\%\) of critical (Table 12.3), and without \(B_{v,44}\) the roll resonance is absurdly large. Its effect on the MSI is the subject of the last section of this chapter.

Common mistake: interpolating the RAOs

HydRA’s results are \(0.1\) rad/s apart, while a roll resonance with \(5\%\) damping is only a few hundredths of a rad/s wide, and the heave and pitch RAOs change fast near the peak of the wave spectrum. The RAOs vary rapidly, but the coefficients \(\boldsymbol{A}\), \(\boldsymbol{B}\) and the loads \(\{\hat{F}\}\) that produce them vary slowly. Interpolate those onto a fine grid (\(0.002\) rad/s here) and solve the equations there. In a test on the KCS, this gave the MSI within \(0.4\) percentage points of a calculation on a three times finer HydRA grid; interpolating the RAOs instead was off by up to \(20\%\).

Irregular frequencies. A panel method of this kind has a numerical flaw: at certain irregular frequencies its integral equation also solves a fictitious problem, the sloshing of water inside the hull, and the results show narrow spurious spikes. Treating the inside of the hull as a box, the lowest irregular frequency is about

\[\begin{align} \omega_{irr}^2 = gk\coth(kT), \qquad k = \pi\sqrt{1/L_{pp}^2 + 1/B^2} \end{align}\]

an encounter frequency, and more follow closely above it. Every spike found in the data lies above \(0.97\,\omega_{irr}\).

The hull is represented by sources on its wetted surface, and those sources also create a potential inside the hull. The source strengths are fixed by the body boundary condition outside. At an irregular frequency, a set of sources exists whose potential outside is zero; its potential is continuous across the hull surface, so inside it is zero on the wetted surface, while on the waterplane inside the hull, the “lid” \(z = 0\), it satisfies the same free-surface condition as outside, \(-\omega^2\phi + g\,\partial\phi/\partial z = 0\). Such sources can be added to any solution, which is then no longer unique, and the numerical solution is spoiled near these frequencies.

For a box of length \(L\), breadth \(B\) and depth \(T\), the interior solutions that vanish on the four walls and on the bottom \(z = -T\) are

\[\begin{align} \phi = \sin\frac{m\pi x}{L}\,\sin\frac{n\pi y}{B}\,\sinh\left(k(z + T)\right), \qquad k^2 = \left(\frac{m\pi}{L}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{n\pi}{B}\right)^2 \end{align}\]

with \(x\) and \(y\) measured from a corner. The lid condition at \(z = 0\) gives \(gk\cosh(kT) = \omega^2\sinh(kT)\), that is \(\omega^2 = gk\coth(kT)\), and the lowest mode, \(m = n = 1\), gives \(k = \pi\sqrt{1/L^2 + 1/B^2}\). Compare the dispersion relation of real waves in water of depth \(h\), \(\omega^2 = gk\tanh(kh)\): there the bottom condition is \(\partial\phi/\partial z = 0\), which gives \(\cosh(k(z + h))\). Inside the hull the potential itself vanishes at the bottom, \(\cosh\) and \(\sinh\) swap places, and \(\tanh\) becomes \(\coth\). Since \(\coth > 1\), the irregular frequencies lie above the frequency of a real wave of the same wave number, and they approach it for a deep hull.

Cutting the data off at \(\omega_{irr}\) would also cut off real response, so only the isolated spikes are replaced, by a spline through the other computed frequencies. A spike is found by comparing the five speeds, which differ by only \(\pm 10\%\): at a spike, one speed departs abruptly from the line through its neighbours (Figure 12.1).

Figure 12.1: The irregular-frequency spike that changes the MSI most among all the hulls: the JBC (bulk carrier) variant with \(f = 1.10\) (\(L_{pp} = 308\) m), in bow quartering seas (\(\beta = 135^\circ\)) at \(1.05\,Fn_{des}\) (\(U = 8.19\) m/s), with the cabin at \(x_P = -138.6\) m, \(y_P = 17.16\) m. The spike is at the computed wave frequency \(\omega = 0.7\) rad/s, met at \(\omega_e = 0.99\) rad/s, just above the estimated lowest irregular frequency of this hull, \(\omega_{irr} = 0.94\) rad/s. (a) The pitch damping \(B_{55}\) against the encounter frequency for the five speeds: above \(\omega_{irr}\) the data scatter. (b) The acceleration integrand \(\omega_e^4|H_P|^2S_{\eta\eta}\) at the computed frequencies; the circled point is replaced. (c) The acceleration spectrum of the cabin as computed (MSI = \(8.1\%\)) and with the spike replaced (MSI = \(4.8\%\)).

12.3 Step 2: The Waves Met by the Ship

A ship advancing at speed \(U\) meets a wave of frequency \(\omega\) and heading \(\beta\) at the encounter frequency (Chapter 7)

\[\begin{align} \omega_e = \omega - \frac{\omega^2 U}{g}\cos\beta = \omega + c\,\omega^2, \qquad c = -\frac{U\cos\beta}{g} \ge 0 \ \text{ for } 90^\circ \le \beta \le 180^\circ \end{align}\]

For these headings \(d\omega_e/d\omega = 1 + 2c\,\omega \ge 1\): every wave frequency is met at one encounter frequency, and every encounter frequency comes from one wave frequency. The band of waves between \(\omega\) and \(\omega + d\omega\) carries the same variance whichever way it is labelled, \(S^e_{\eta\eta}\,d\omega_e = S_{\eta\eta}\,d\omega\), so the spectrum of the waves met by the ship is

\[\begin{align} S^{e}_{\eta\eta}(\omega_e) = \frac{S_{\eta\eta}(\omega)}{1 + 2c\,\omega}, \qquad \omega = \omega(\omega_e) \end{align}\]

Change the speed and heading below, and compare the areas under the three curves.

Key point

Speed squeezes more wave crests into each second, so the encounter spectrum is lower, wider and moved to higher frequencies, but its area is that of the wave spectrum: speed cannot make the waves higher. Relabelling the frequency axis without dividing by \(d\omega_e/d\omega\) is the most common mistake of this step, and it can double the variance of the waves.

12.4 Step 3: The Vertical Motion of the Cabin

To first order, a point \(P\) of the hull at \((x_P, y_P, z_P)\) moves vertically by \(s_P = \xi_3 + y_P\,\xi_4 - x_P\,\xi_5\): heave, plus roll times the distance to port, minus pitch (positive bow down) times the distance forward. In a regular wave every mode is a complex amplitude, \(\xi_j = \mathrm{Re}\{A H_j e^{i\omega_e t}\}\), so the RAO of the vertical motion of the cabin is the complex sum

\[\begin{align} H_P = H_3 + y_P H_4 - x_P H_5 \end{align}\]

with the rotations in rad/m. Heave, roll and pitch do not peak at the same time, and the squared magnitude has three squares and three cross terms:

\[\begin{align} |H_P|^2 = \underbrace{|H_3|^2 + y_P^2|H_4|^2 + x_P^2 |H_5|^2}_{\text{squares}} + \underbrace{2y_P\,\mathrm{Re}\left\{H_3 H_4^{*}\right\} - 2x_P\,\mathrm{Re}\left\{H_3 H_5^{*}\right\} - 2x_P y_P\,\mathrm{Re}\left\{H_4 H_5^{*}\right\}}_{\text{cross terms, set by the phases}} \end{align}\]

The tool below splits the acceleration of the cabin into these six terms, for any hull and case. On the left, each term weighted as in the acceleration spectrum (Step 4); on the right, the area under each curve, which is what the term adds to the variance \(\sigma_a^2\) of the acceleration.

Key point

The cross terms are as large as the squares, and they are often negative: at an aft cabin, heave and pitch are more than \(90^\circ\) apart and partly cancel. For the KCS in head seas, adding only the squares (as if the modes were independent) would make \(\sigma_a^2\) twice too large, and adding the magnitudes would be worse still. The phases of the RAOs are not optional.

12.4.1 Example: one wave component of the KCS

The KCS advances at its design speed, \(U = 12.35\) m/s (\(24\) kn), in bow quartering seas (\(\beta = 135^\circ\)). Take the wave component at the peak of the acceleration spectrum of the cabin: \(\omega = 0.528\) rad/s (\(\lambda = 221\) m), met at \(\omega_e = 0.776\) rad/s. The cabin is at \(x_P = -80.5\) m, \(y_P = 12.88\) m. From the equations of motion:

Table 12.1: One wave component of the KCS in bow quartering seas at \(24\) kn: RAOs (magnitude and phase relative to the wave crest at \(O\)) and their contributions to the vertical motion of the cabin.
RAO Contribution to \(H_P\) (m/m)
Heave \(H_3 = 1.379\) m/m \(\angle -50^\circ\) \(H_3 = 1.379 \angle -50^\circ\)
Roll \(H_4 = 0.106\) deg/m \(\angle -54^\circ\) \(y_P H_4 = 0.024 \angle -54^\circ\)
Pitch \(H_5 = 1.183\) deg/m \(\angle -167^\circ\) \(-x_P H_5 = 1.662 \angle -167^\circ\)
Cabin \(H_P = 1.625 \angle -116^\circ\)

Pitch at the aft cabin is \(117^\circ\) away from heave, so the two partly cancel (Figure 12.2). The cabin moves \(1.62\) m per metre of wave amplitude. Adding the magnitudes would give \(3.06\) m, and adding the squares \(2.16\) m. Roll adds only \(0.024\) m: the KCS rolls little in this sea.

Figure 12.2: (a) The contributions of heave, roll and pitch to the vertical motion of the cabin of the KCS (Table 12.1), drawn tip to tail as phasors, and their sum \(H_P\). Roll is too small to see. (b) Where this wave component lies in the acceleration spectrum of the cabin.

12.4.2 From motion to acceleration

The cabin is fixed in the hull, and the hull oscillates at the encounter frequency. Differentiating twice in time gives the RAO of the vertical acceleration of the cabin:

\[\begin{align} H_a = -\omega_e^2\,H_P, \qquad |H_a| = \omega_e^2\,|H_P| \end{align}\]

Common mistake: differentiating at the wave frequency

In the example, \(|H_a| = \omega_e^2|H_P| = 0.98\) m/s\(^2\) per metre of wave amplitude. Using the wave frequency instead gives \(\omega^2|H_P| = 0.45\) m/s\(^2\), 54% too little.

12.5 Step 4: The Acceleration Spectrum and the MSI

The acceleration of the cabin is a linear response to the waves, so its spectrum is the encounter spectrum of the waves times \(|H_a|^2\) (Chapter 9):

\[\begin{align} \boxed{S_{aa}(\omega_e) = \omega_e^4\,|H_P|^2\,S^e_{\eta\eta}(\omega_e)} \end{align}\]

Its moments are most easily integrated over the wave frequency, where the Jacobian of Step 2 cancels:

\[\begin{align} m_n^a = \int_0^\infty \omega_e^n S_{aa}\,d\omega_e = \int_0^\infty \omega_e(\omega)^{n+4}\,|H_P(\omega)|^2\,S_{\eta\eta}(\omega)\,d\omega, \qquad \sigma_a = \sqrt{m_0^a}, \quad \bar{\omega}_e = \frac{m_1^a}{m_0^a} \end{align}\]

and the mean absolute acceleration of the zero-mean Gaussian process is \(\bar{a} = \sqrt{2/\pi}\,\sigma_a\). With \(\bar{a}\) and \(\bar{\omega}_e\) the MSI follows from the model of Chapter 11. What do \(\sigma_a\) and \(\bar{a}\) look like in time? The tool below builds three minutes of the random acceleration of the cabin from its spectrum, by adding all the wave components with random phases, and its histogram over half an hour.

Key point

The acceleration of the cabin is random, but its statistics are fixed by the spectrum. The histogram is the Gaussian of standard deviation \(\sigma_a\), and the average height of \(|a(t)|\) is \(\bar{a} \approx 0.8\,\sigma_a\): this is the number, with the mean frequency \(\bar{\omega}_e\), that the MSI model needs.

Table 12.2: Fraction of the variance \(m_0\) of the project wave spectrum between \(\omega_{min}\) and \(\omega_{max}\), and the standard deviation of the vertical acceleration of a point that follows the water surface (\(H_P = 1\), \(U = 0\)) over the same range.
\(\omega_{min}\) (rad/s) \(\omega_{max}\) (rad/s) Fraction of \(m_0\) \(\sigma_a\) of the surface (m/s\(^2\))
\(0.2\) \(1.0\) \(0.9446\) \(0.411\)
\(0.2\) \(1.5\) \(0.9888\) \(0.532\)
\(0.2\) \(2.0\) \(0.9964\) \(0.605\)
\(0.2\) \(3.0\) \(0.9993\) \(0.695\)
\(0.2\) \(5.0\) \(0.9999\) \(0.794\)

The waves carry \(99\%\) of their variance below \(1.5\) rad/s, but the acceleration is weighted by \(\omega_e^4\), and the JONSWAP spectrum decays only as \(\omega^{-5}\): the acceleration of a point that follows the water surface keeps growing as the range is extended (Table 12.2). The acceleration of a ship stays finite only because its RAOs fall off in short waves. Check that your \(\sigma_a\) does not change when the upper limit is raised. For the combatant, whose heave resonance lies near \(1.1\) rad/s, stopping at \(1.0\) rad/s instead of \(1.5\) rad/s would lower the beam-sea MSI from \(5.8\%\) to \(3.5\%\).

Raising the limit is safe only where the RAOs can be trusted. In head and bow quartering seas the RAOs are therefore tapered to zero, with a cosine, over the last \(10\%\) below the wave frequency at which \(\lambda = L_{pp}/4\), \(\omega = \sqrt{8\pi g/L_{pp}}\): from \(0.88\) rad/s for the tanker to \(1.32\) rad/s for the combatant. Waves this short hardly move the hulls along their length, and the taper keeps any spurious values there, magnified by \(\omega_e^4\), out of the integral. It changes no MSI in these headings by more than about \(0.2\) points. In beam seas a wave runs across the beam, and the short waves still move the ship, as the combatant shows, so the RAOs are left untapered.

12.6 The Hulls at a Glance

Table 12.3: The baseline hulls: the position of the cabin, the roll natural frequency, the wave-making roll damping there as a fraction of critical, the viscous roll damping added (\(\zeta_v = 0.05\)), and the estimated lowest irregular frequency.
Hull Type \(L_{pp}\) (m) \(Fn_{des}\) \(x_P\) (m) \(y_P\) (m) \(\omega_n\) roll (rad/s) \(\zeta\) wave-making \(B_{v,44}\) (MN m s) \(\omega_{irr}\) (rad/s)
KVLCC2 tanker 320.0 0.142 -144.0 23.20 0.296 0.0001 6007.3 0.81
JBC bulk carrier 280.0 0.142 -126.0 18.00 0.358 0.0004 2620.7 0.92
KCS container ship 230.0 0.260 -80.5 12.88 0.165 < 0.0001 181.9 1.11
S175 container ship 175.0 0.250 -61.2 10.16 0.362 < 0.0001 71.7 1.22
DTMB 5415 surface combatant 142.0 0.413 -21.3 7.62 0.541 0.0089 30.3 1.34
Table 12.4: MSI (%) in two hours at the cabin at the design speed.
Hull \(f\) \(\beta = 90^\circ\) \(\beta = 135^\circ\) \(\beta = 180^\circ\)
KVLCC2 0.90 1.0 2.8 1.3
0.95 1.0 2.5 1.3
1.00 1.1 2.4 1.0
1.05 1.2 2.3 0.8
1.10 1.2 2.2 0.7
JBC 0.90 1.7 6.4 3.5
0.95 1.8 6.1 2.9
1.00 1.8 5.6 2.4
1.05 1.9 5.1 1.9
1.10 1.9 4.5 1.6
KCS 0.90 3.8 12.9 11.5
0.95 3.9 12.4 10.1
1.00 4.0 11.7 8.8
1.05 4.1 10.9 7.8
1.10 4.2 10.1 6.8
S175 0.90 6.3 21.9 23.3
0.95 6.4 21.5 22.6
1.00 6.4 21.0 21.7
1.05 6.5 20.5 20.7
1.10 6.6 20.0 19.6
DTMB 5415 0.90 5.6 25.3 28.3
0.95 5.7 24.3 26.6
1.00 5.8 23.1 24.9
1.05 5.9 22.1 23.2
1.10 5.9 20.9 21.3
Member \(\beta\) (deg) \(Fn/Fn_{des}\) \(U\) (m/s) \(\sigma_a\) (m/s\(^2\)) \(\bar{a}\) (m/s\(^2\)) \(\bar{\omega}_e\) (rad/s) \(\mu_{MSI}\) MSI (%)
KVLCC2_L0p900 90 0.90 6.79 0.328 0.261 0.532 -0.645 1.0
KVLCC2_L0p900 90 0.95 7.17 0.329 0.262 0.531 -0.644 1.0
KVLCC2_L0p900 90 1.00 7.55 0.330 0.263 0.530 -0.643 1.0
KVLCC2_L0p900 90 1.05 7.92 0.331 0.264 0.529 -0.642 1.0
KVLCC2_L0p900 90 1.10 8.30 0.332 0.265 0.528 -0.641 1.0
KVLCC2_L0p900 135 0.90 6.79 0.417 0.333 0.571 -0.681 2.4
KVLCC2_L0p900 135 0.95 7.17 0.421 0.336 0.573 -0.684 2.5
KVLCC2_L0p900 135 1.00 7.55 0.428 0.342 0.582 -0.691 2.8
KVLCC2_L0p900 135 1.05 7.92 0.429 0.342 0.578 -0.687 2.7
KVLCC2_L0p900 135 1.10 8.30 0.432 0.345 0.580 -0.689 2.8
KVLCC2_L0p900 180 0.90 6.79 0.309 0.247 0.569 -0.680 1.1
KVLCC2_L0p900 180 0.95 7.17 0.318 0.254 0.575 -0.685 1.2
KVLCC2_L0p900 180 1.00 7.55 0.325 0.259 0.578 -0.688 1.3
KVLCC2_L0p900 180 1.05 7.92 0.333 0.266 0.581 -0.690 1.4
KVLCC2_L0p900 180 1.10 8.30 0.340 0.271 0.585 -0.693 1.5
KVLCC2_L0p950 90 0.90 6.98 0.328 0.262 0.536 -0.648 1.0
KVLCC2_L0p950 90 0.95 7.37 0.329 0.263 0.534 -0.647 1.0
KVLCC2_L0p950 90 1.00 7.75 0.330 0.264 0.533 -0.646 1.0
KVLCC2_L0p950 90 1.05 8.14 0.331 0.264 0.533 -0.645 1.0
KVLCC2_L0p950 90 1.10 8.53 0.332 0.265 0.532 -0.644 1.0
KVLCC2_L0p950 135 0.90 6.98 0.408 0.326 0.574 -0.684 2.4
KVLCC2_L0p950 135 0.95 7.37 0.412 0.329 0.576 -0.686 2.4
KVLCC2_L0p950 135 1.00 7.75 0.416 0.332 0.579 -0.689 2.5
KVLCC2_L0p950 135 1.05 8.14 0.423 0.338 0.581 -0.690 2.7
KVLCC2_L0p950 135 1.10 8.53 0.428 0.342 0.588 -0.695 2.8
KVLCC2_L0p950 180 0.90 6.98 0.290 0.231 0.571 -0.682 0.9
KVLCC2_L0p950 180 0.95 7.37 0.300 0.239 0.577 -0.687 1.0
KVLCC2_L0p950 180 1.00 7.75 0.313 0.250 0.591 -0.698 1.3
KVLCC2_L0p950 180 1.05 8.14 0.317 0.253 0.584 -0.693 1.3
KVLCC2_L0p950 180 1.10 8.53 0.325 0.259 0.589 -0.696 1.4
KVLCC2_L1p000 90 0.90 7.16 0.331 0.264 0.541 -0.654 1.1
KVLCC2_L1p000 90 0.95 7.56 0.332 0.265 0.540 -0.653 1.1
KVLCC2_L1p000 90 1.00 7.95 0.333 0.265 0.539 -0.652 1.1
KVLCC2_L1p000 90 1.05 8.35 0.334 0.266 0.538 -0.651 1.1
KVLCC2_L1p000 90 1.10 8.75 0.335 0.267 0.537 -0.650 1.1
KVLCC2_L1p000 135 0.90 7.16 0.397 0.317 0.576 -0.686 2.2
KVLCC2_L1p000 135 0.95 7.56 0.403 0.321 0.579 -0.689 2.3
KVLCC2_L1p000 135 1.00 7.95 0.408 0.325 0.582 -0.691 2.4
KVLCC2_L1p000 135 1.05 8.35 0.426 0.340 0.587 -0.695 2.8
KVLCC2_L1p000 135 1.10 8.75 0.421 0.336 0.589 -0.696 2.7
KVLCC2_L1p000 180 0.90 7.16 0.272 0.217 0.573 -0.684 0.8
KVLCC2_L1p000 180 0.95 7.56 0.282 0.225 0.581 -0.690 0.9
KVLCC2_L1p000 180 1.00 7.95 0.292 0.233 0.584 -0.692 1.0
KVLCC2_L1p000 180 1.05 8.35 0.299 0.239 0.587 -0.695 1.1
KVLCC2_L1p000 180 1.10 8.75 0.313 0.250 0.601 -0.706 1.3
KVLCC2_L1p050 90 0.90 7.34 0.333 0.266 0.547 -0.659 1.2
KVLCC2_L1p050 90 0.95 7.74 0.334 0.267 0.546 -0.658 1.2
KVLCC2_L1p050 90 1.00 8.15 0.335 0.267 0.545 -0.657 1.2
KVLCC2_L1p050 90 1.05 8.56 0.336 0.268 0.544 -0.656 1.2
KVLCC2_L1p050 90 1.10 8.97 0.337 0.269 0.543 -0.656 1.2
KVLCC2_L1p050 135 0.90 7.34 0.386 0.308 0.579 -0.688 2.1
KVLCC2_L1p050 135 0.95 7.74 0.392 0.313 0.581 -0.690 2.2
KVLCC2_L1p050 135 1.00 8.15 0.398 0.318 0.584 -0.693 2.3
KVLCC2_L1p050 135 1.05 8.56 0.405 0.323 0.588 -0.695 2.5
KVLCC2_L1p050 135 1.10 8.97 0.414 0.330 0.591 -0.698 2.6
KVLCC2_L1p050 180 0.90 7.34 0.254 0.202 0.577 -0.687 0.6
KVLCC2_L1p050 180 0.95 7.74 0.265 0.211 0.585 -0.693 0.7
KVLCC2_L1p050 180 1.00 8.15 0.273 0.217 0.586 -0.694 0.8
KVLCC2_L1p050 180 1.05 8.56 0.280 0.224 0.590 -0.697 0.9
KVLCC2_L1p050 180 1.10 8.97 0.288 0.230 0.595 -0.701 1.0
KVLCC2_L1p100 90 0.90 7.51 0.336 0.268 0.551 -0.664 1.2
KVLCC2_L1p100 90 0.95 7.93 0.337 0.269 0.550 -0.663 1.2
KVLCC2_L1p100 90 1.00 8.34 0.337 0.269 0.549 -0.662 1.2
KVLCC2_L1p100 90 1.05 8.76 0.338 0.270 0.549 -0.661 1.2
KVLCC2_L1p100 90 1.10 9.18 0.339 0.271 0.548 -0.660 1.2
KVLCC2_L1p100 135 0.90 7.51 0.372 0.297 0.580 -0.689 1.9
KVLCC2_L1p100 135 0.95 7.93 0.380 0.303 0.583 -0.691 2.0
KVLCC2_L1p100 135 1.00 8.34 0.388 0.310 0.587 -0.695 2.2
KVLCC2_L1p100 135 1.05 8.76 0.396 0.316 0.589 -0.697 2.3
KVLCC2_L1p100 135 1.10 9.18 0.406 0.324 0.594 -0.700 2.6
KVLCC2_L1p100 180 0.90 7.51 0.232 0.185 0.574 -0.684 0.5
KVLCC2_L1p100 180 0.95 7.93 0.252 0.201 0.602 -0.706 0.7
KVLCC2_L1p100 180 1.00 8.34 0.253 0.202 0.590 -0.697 0.7
KVLCC2_L1p100 180 1.05 8.76 0.266 0.212 0.604 -0.708 0.8
KVLCC2_L1p100 180 1.10 9.18 0.268 0.213 0.599 -0.704 0.8
JBC_L0p900 90 0.90 6.35 0.368 0.294 0.563 -0.675 1.7
JBC_L0p900 90 0.95 6.71 0.370 0.295 0.563 -0.674 1.7
JBC_L0p900 90 1.00 7.06 0.372 0.297 0.562 -0.673 1.7
JBC_L0p900 90 1.05 7.41 0.374 0.298 0.561 -0.673 1.7
JBC_L0p900 90 1.10 7.77 0.376 0.300 0.560 -0.672 1.8
JBC_L0p900 135 0.90 6.35 0.560 0.447 0.606 -0.709 5.7
JBC_L0p900 135 0.95 6.71 0.574 0.458 0.610 -0.712 6.1
JBC_L0p900 135 1.00 7.06 0.585 0.466 0.612 -0.713 6.4
JBC_L0p900 135 1.05 7.41 0.595 0.475 0.615 -0.715 6.7
JBC_L0p900 135 1.10 7.77 0.609 0.486 0.621 -0.719 7.2
JBC_L0p900 180 0.90 6.35 0.429 0.342 0.607 -0.710 3.1
JBC_L0p900 180 0.95 6.71 0.438 0.350 0.612 -0.713 3.3
JBC_L0p900 180 1.00 7.06 0.446 0.356 0.615 -0.715 3.5
JBC_L0p900 180 1.05 7.41 0.458 0.365 0.629 -0.725 3.9
JBC_L0p900 180 1.10 7.77 0.462 0.369 0.622 -0.720 3.9
JBC_L0p950 90 0.90 6.53 0.368 0.293 0.567 -0.678 1.7
JBC_L0p950 90 0.95 6.89 0.369 0.295 0.566 -0.677 1.7
JBC_L0p950 90 1.00 7.25 0.371 0.296 0.565 -0.677 1.8
JBC_L0p950 90 1.05 7.62 0.373 0.297 0.565 -0.676 1.8
JBC_L0p950 90 1.10 7.98 0.375 0.299 0.564 -0.675 1.8
JBC_L0p950 135 0.90 6.53 0.545 0.435 0.609 -0.711 5.4
JBC_L0p950 135 0.95 6.89 0.558 0.445 0.613 -0.715 5.8
JBC_L0p950 135 1.00 7.25 0.567 0.452 0.616 -0.716 6.1
JBC_L0p950 135 1.05 7.62 0.577 0.460 0.618 -0.718 6.3
JBC_L0p950 135 1.10 7.98 0.588 0.469 0.623 -0.721 6.7
JBC_L0p950 180 0.90 6.53 0.393 0.314 0.610 -0.712 2.5
JBC_L0p950 180 0.95 6.89 0.404 0.322 0.617 -0.717 2.8
JBC_L0p950 180 1.00 7.25 0.412 0.329 0.618 -0.718 2.9
JBC_L0p950 180 1.05 7.62 0.422 0.337 0.622 -0.720 3.1
JBC_L0p950 180 1.10 7.98 0.431 0.344 0.625 -0.723 3.4
JBC_L1p000 90 0.90 6.70 0.369 0.294 0.573 -0.683 1.8
JBC_L1p000 90 0.95 7.07 0.370 0.295 0.572 -0.682 1.8
JBC_L1p000 90 1.00 7.44 0.372 0.297 0.571 -0.682 1.8
JBC_L1p000 90 1.05 7.81 0.373 0.298 0.570 -0.681 1.8
JBC_L1p000 90 1.10 8.19 0.375 0.299 0.569 -0.680 1.8
JBC_L1p000 135 0.90 6.70 0.525 0.419 0.612 -0.713 5.0
JBC_L1p000 135 0.95 7.07 0.537 0.428 0.616 -0.717 5.4
JBC_L1p000 135 1.00 7.44 0.545 0.435 0.618 -0.718 5.6
JBC_L1p000 135 1.05 7.81 0.554 0.442 0.621 -0.720 5.9
JBC_L1p000 135 1.10 8.19 0.565 0.451 0.625 -0.722 6.2
JBC_L1p000 180 0.90 6.70 0.358 0.286 0.612 -0.713 2.0
JBC_L1p000 180 0.95 7.07 0.368 0.294 0.615 -0.716 2.2
JBC_L1p000 180 1.00 7.44 0.379 0.302 0.620 -0.719 2.4
JBC_L1p000 180 1.05 7.81 0.391 0.312 0.626 -0.723 2.6
JBC_L1p000 180 1.10 8.19 0.401 0.320 0.628 -0.724 2.8
JBC_L1p050 90 0.90 6.86 0.370 0.295 0.578 -0.687 1.8
JBC_L1p050 90 0.95 7.24 0.371 0.296 0.577 -0.687 1.9
JBC_L1p050 90 1.00 7.62 0.373 0.297 0.576 -0.686 1.9
JBC_L1p050 90 1.05 8.01 0.374 0.298 0.575 -0.685 1.9
JBC_L1p050 90 1.10 8.39 0.375 0.300 0.575 -0.685 1.9
JBC_L1p050 135 0.90 6.86 0.505 0.403 0.618 -0.718 4.7
JBC_L1p050 135 0.95 7.24 0.512 0.408 0.618 -0.718 4.9
JBC_L1p050 135 1.00 7.62 0.520 0.415 0.620 -0.719 5.1
JBC_L1p050 135 1.05 8.01 0.529 0.422 0.624 -0.721 5.4
JBC_L1p050 135 1.10 8.39 0.541 0.432 0.628 -0.724 5.7
JBC_L1p050 180 0.90 6.86 0.325 0.259 0.612 -0.714 1.5
JBC_L1p050 180 0.95 7.24 0.336 0.268 0.617 -0.717 1.7
JBC_L1p050 180 1.00 7.62 0.348 0.278 0.622 -0.721 1.9
JBC_L1p050 180 1.05 8.01 0.359 0.287 0.626 -0.723 2.1
JBC_L1p050 180 1.10 8.39 0.372 0.297 0.630 -0.726 2.4
JBC_L1p100 90 0.90 7.02 0.371 0.296 0.583 -0.692 1.9
JBC_L1p100 90 0.95 7.41 0.372 0.297 0.582 -0.691 1.9
JBC_L1p100 90 1.00 7.80 0.374 0.298 0.581 -0.690 1.9
JBC_L1p100 90 1.05 8.19 0.375 0.299 0.581 -0.690 2.0
JBC_L1p100 90 1.10 8.58 0.377 0.300 0.580 -0.689 2.0
JBC_L1p100 135 0.90 7.02 0.474 0.378 0.617 -0.717 4.1
JBC_L1p100 135 0.95 7.41 0.485 0.387 0.620 -0.719 4.3
JBC_L1p100 135 1.00 7.80 0.493 0.393 0.621 -0.720 4.5
JBC_L1p100 135 1.05 8.19 0.505 0.403 0.625 -0.722 4.8
JBC_L1p100 135 1.10 8.58 0.515 0.411 0.628 -0.724 5.1
JBC_L1p100 180 0.90 7.02 0.295 0.236 0.614 -0.715 1.2
JBC_L1p100 180 0.95 7.41 0.306 0.244 0.618 -0.718 1.3
JBC_L1p100 180 1.00 7.80 0.319 0.255 0.627 -0.723 1.6
JBC_L1p100 180 1.05 8.19 0.331 0.264 0.629 -0.725 1.7
JBC_L1p100 180 1.10 8.58 0.343 0.274 0.632 -0.727 1.9
KCS_L0p900 90 0.90 10.54 0.431 0.344 0.662 -0.744 3.8
KCS_L0p900 90 0.95 11.13 0.432 0.345 0.662 -0.744 3.8
KCS_L0p900 90 1.00 11.71 0.434 0.346 0.662 -0.744 3.8
KCS_L0p900 90 1.05 12.30 0.435 0.347 0.662 -0.745 3.9
KCS_L0p900 90 1.10 12.89 0.436 0.348 0.662 -0.745 3.9
KCS_L0p900 135 0.90 10.54 0.644 0.514 0.750 -0.783 10.7
KCS_L0p900 135 0.95 11.13 0.680 0.543 0.755 -0.784 11.9
KCS_L0p900 135 1.00 11.71 0.707 0.564 0.765 -0.787 12.9
KCS_L0p900 135 1.05 12.30 0.739 0.589 0.770 -0.789 14.0
KCS_L0p900 135 1.10 12.89 0.766 0.612 0.775 -0.790 15.0
KCS_L0p900 180 0.90 10.54 0.597 0.477 0.770 -0.789 9.5
KCS_L0p900 180 0.95 11.13 0.627 0.500 0.781 -0.792 10.6
KCS_L0p900 180 1.00 11.71 0.652 0.521 0.788 -0.794 11.5
KCS_L0p900 180 1.05 12.30 0.679 0.542 0.796 -0.796 12.4
KCS_L0p900 180 1.10 12.89 0.707 0.564 0.805 -0.798 13.5
KCS_L0p950 90 0.90 10.83 0.432 0.345 0.666 -0.747 3.8
KCS_L0p950 90 0.95 11.43 0.433 0.346 0.666 -0.747 3.9
KCS_L0p950 90 1.00 12.04 0.434 0.347 0.666 -0.747 3.9
KCS_L0p950 90 1.05 12.64 0.436 0.348 0.666 -0.747 3.9
KCS_L0p950 90 1.10 13.24 0.437 0.349 0.666 -0.747 4.0
KCS_L0p950 135 0.90 10.83 0.628 0.501 0.754 -0.784 10.2
KCS_L0p950 135 0.95 11.43 0.667 0.532 0.763 -0.787 11.6
KCS_L0p950 135 1.00 12.04 0.688 0.549 0.770 -0.789 12.4
KCS_L0p950 135 1.05 12.64 0.717 0.572 0.775 -0.791 13.4
KCS_L0p950 135 1.10 13.24 0.746 0.595 0.781 -0.792 14.4
KCS_L0p950 180 0.90 10.83 0.553 0.442 0.774 -0.790 8.2
KCS_L0p950 180 0.95 11.43 0.580 0.463 0.782 -0.793 9.1
KCS_L0p950 180 1.00 12.04 0.607 0.485 0.793 -0.796 10.1
KCS_L0p950 180 1.05 12.64 0.635 0.507 0.802 -0.798 11.1
KCS_L0p950 180 1.10 13.24 0.665 0.530 0.811 -0.800 12.2
KCS_L1p000 90 0.90 11.11 0.434 0.346 0.672 -0.750 4.0
KCS_L1p000 90 0.95 11.73 0.435 0.347 0.672 -0.750 4.0
KCS_L1p000 90 1.00 12.35 0.436 0.348 0.672 -0.750 4.0
KCS_L1p000 90 1.05 12.97 0.437 0.349 0.672 -0.750 4.0
KCS_L1p000 90 1.10 13.58 0.439 0.350 0.672 -0.750 4.1
KCS_L1p000 135 0.90 11.11 0.610 0.487 0.759 -0.786 9.8
KCS_L1p000 135 0.95 11.73 0.647 0.516 0.776 -0.791 11.1
KCS_L1p000 135 1.00 12.35 0.665 0.531 0.775 -0.790 11.7
KCS_L1p000 135 1.05 12.97 0.691 0.551 0.780 -0.792 12.6
KCS_L1p000 135 1.10 13.58 0.720 0.575 0.787 -0.794 13.7
KCS_L1p000 180 0.90 11.11 0.514 0.410 0.779 -0.792 7.1
KCS_L1p000 180 0.95 11.73 0.537 0.429 0.786 -0.794 7.9
KCS_L1p000 180 1.00 12.35 0.566 0.452 0.796 -0.796 8.8
KCS_L1p000 180 1.05 12.97 0.596 0.476 0.806 -0.799 9.9
KCS_L1p000 180 1.10 13.58 0.628 0.501 0.815 -0.801 11.0
KCS_L1p050 90 0.90 11.39 0.435 0.347 0.677 -0.752 4.0
KCS_L1p050 90 0.95 12.02 0.437 0.348 0.677 -0.752 4.1
KCS_L1p050 90 1.00 12.65 0.438 0.349 0.677 -0.752 4.1
KCS_L1p050 90 1.05 13.29 0.439 0.350 0.677 -0.752 4.1
KCS_L1p050 90 1.10 13.92 0.440 0.351 0.677 -0.752 4.1
KCS_L1p050 135 0.90 11.39 0.588 0.469 0.760 -0.786 9.1
KCS_L1p050 135 0.95 12.02 0.612 0.489 0.770 -0.789 10.0
KCS_L1p050 135 1.00 12.65 0.639 0.510 0.778 -0.791 10.9
KCS_L1p050 135 1.05 13.29 0.663 0.529 0.784 -0.793 11.8
KCS_L1p050 135 1.10 13.92 0.690 0.551 0.791 -0.795 12.7
KCS_L1p050 180 0.90 11.39 0.475 0.379 0.777 -0.791 6.0
KCS_L1p050 180 0.95 12.02 0.502 0.401 0.790 -0.795 6.9
KCS_L1p050 180 1.00 12.65 0.532 0.424 0.801 -0.798 7.8
KCS_L1p050 180 1.05 13.29 0.560 0.446 0.806 -0.799 8.7
KCS_L1p050 180 1.10 13.92 0.592 0.472 0.817 -0.801 9.8
KCS_L1p100 90 0.90 11.66 0.437 0.349 0.682 -0.755 4.1
KCS_L1p100 90 0.95 12.30 0.438 0.350 0.682 -0.755 4.2
KCS_L1p100 90 1.00 12.95 0.439 0.351 0.682 -0.755 4.2
KCS_L1p100 90 1.05 13.60 0.440 0.351 0.682 -0.755 4.2
KCS_L1p100 90 1.10 14.25 0.442 0.352 0.682 -0.755 4.2
KCS_L1p100 135 0.90 11.66 0.563 0.450 0.760 -0.786 8.4
KCS_L1p100 135 0.95 12.30 0.586 0.468 0.772 -0.790 9.2
KCS_L1p100 135 1.00 12.95 0.612 0.488 0.781 -0.792 10.1
KCS_L1p100 135 1.05 13.60 0.635 0.506 0.786 -0.794 10.9
KCS_L1p100 135 1.10 14.25 0.662 0.528 0.795 -0.796 11.9
KCS_L1p100 180 0.90 11.66 0.441 0.352 0.777 -0.791 5.1
KCS_L1p100 180 0.95 12.30 0.468 0.374 0.789 -0.795 5.9
KCS_L1p100 180 1.00 12.95 0.496 0.396 0.799 -0.797 6.8
KCS_L1p100 180 1.05 13.60 0.528 0.421 0.812 -0.800 7.8
KCS_L1p100 180 1.10 14.25 0.557 0.445 0.822 -0.802 8.8
S175_L0p900 90 0.90 8.84 0.499 0.398 0.728 -0.775 6.2
S175_L0p900 90 0.95 9.33 0.501 0.400 0.728 -0.775 6.2
S175_L0p900 90 1.00 9.83 0.503 0.401 0.728 -0.775 6.3
S175_L0p900 90 1.05 10.32 0.505 0.403 0.728 -0.775 6.3
S175_L0p900 90 1.10 10.81 0.506 0.404 0.728 -0.775 6.4
S175_L0p900 135 0.90 8.84 0.886 0.707 0.854 -0.808 20.2
S175_L0p900 135 0.95 9.33 0.900 0.718 0.841 -0.806 20.5
S175_L0p900 135 1.00 9.83 0.938 0.748 0.849 -0.807 21.9
S175_L0p900 135 1.05 10.32 0.977 0.779 0.856 -0.808 23.3
S175_L0p900 135 1.10 10.81 1.013 0.808 0.860 -0.809 24.6
S175_L0p900 180 0.90 8.84 0.886 0.707 0.841 -0.806 20.0
S175_L0p900 180 0.95 9.33 0.929 0.741 0.848 -0.807 21.6
S175_L0p900 180 1.00 9.83 0.977 0.779 0.857 -0.809 23.3
S175_L0p900 180 1.05 10.32 1.033 0.824 0.861 -0.809 25.3
S175_L0p900 180 1.10 10.81 1.082 0.863 0.871 -0.811 27.0
S175_L0p950 90 0.90 9.08 0.500 0.399 0.735 -0.777 6.3
S175_L0p950 90 0.95 9.59 0.502 0.400 0.735 -0.777 6.3
S175_L0p950 90 1.00 10.09 0.503 0.402 0.735 -0.777 6.4
S175_L0p950 90 1.05 10.60 0.505 0.403 0.735 -0.778 6.4
S175_L0p950 90 1.10 11.10 0.507 0.404 0.735 -0.778 6.5
S175_L0p950 135 0.90 9.08 0.854 0.682 0.846 -0.807 19.0
S175_L0p950 135 0.95 9.59 0.887 0.707 0.848 -0.807 20.1
S175_L0p950 135 1.00 10.09 0.924 0.737 0.857 -0.809 21.5
S175_L0p950 135 1.05 10.60 0.960 0.766 0.862 -0.809 22.8
S175_L0p950 135 1.10 11.10 0.996 0.795 0.867 -0.810 24.1
S175_L0p950 180 0.90 9.08 0.857 0.684 0.842 -0.806 19.1
S175_L0p950 180 0.95 9.59 0.903 0.720 0.852 -0.808 20.7
S175_L0p950 180 1.00 10.09 0.953 0.760 0.862 -0.809 22.6
S175_L0p950 180 1.05 10.60 1.007 0.804 0.867 -0.810 24.5
S175_L0p950 180 1.10 11.10 1.056 0.843 0.876 -0.811 26.2
S175_L1p000 90 0.90 9.32 0.501 0.400 0.742 -0.780 6.4
S175_L1p000 90 0.95 9.84 0.502 0.401 0.742 -0.780 6.4
S175_L1p000 90 1.00 10.36 0.504 0.402 0.742 -0.780 6.4
S175_L1p000 90 1.05 10.87 0.506 0.403 0.742 -0.780 6.5
S175_L1p000 90 1.10 11.39 0.507 0.405 0.742 -0.780 6.5
S175_L1p000 135 0.90 9.32 0.837 0.668 0.849 -0.807 18.4
S175_L1p000 135 0.95 9.84 0.871 0.695 0.853 -0.808 19.6
S175_L1p000 135 1.00 10.36 0.908 0.724 0.863 -0.810 21.0
S175_L1p000 135 1.05 10.87 0.943 0.752 0.868 -0.810 22.3
S175_L1p000 135 1.10 11.39 0.980 0.782 0.874 -0.811 23.6
S175_L1p000 180 0.90 9.32 0.831 0.663 0.842 -0.806 18.1
S175_L1p000 180 0.95 9.84 0.879 0.701 0.856 -0.808 20.0
S175_L1p000 180 1.00 10.36 0.926 0.739 0.865 -0.810 21.7
S175_L1p000 180 1.05 10.87 0.980 0.782 0.871 -0.811 23.6
S175_L1p000 180 1.10 11.39 1.029 0.821 0.882 -0.812 25.4
S175_L1p050 90 0.90 9.55 0.502 0.400 0.748 -0.782 6.5
S175_L1p050 90 0.95 10.08 0.503 0.402 0.748 -0.782 6.5
S175_L1p050 90 1.00 10.61 0.505 0.403 0.748 -0.782 6.5
S175_L1p050 90 1.05 11.14 0.506 0.404 0.748 -0.782 6.6
S175_L1p050 90 1.10 11.67 0.508 0.405 0.748 -0.782 6.6
S175_L1p050 135 0.90 9.55 0.818 0.653 0.850 -0.807 17.8
S175_L1p050 135 0.95 10.08 0.853 0.680 0.856 -0.808 19.1
S175_L1p050 135 1.00 10.61 0.891 0.711 0.868 -0.810 20.5
S175_L1p050 135 1.05 11.14 0.926 0.739 0.873 -0.811 21.8
S175_L1p050 135 1.10 11.67 0.963 0.768 0.878 -0.812 23.1
S175_L1p050 180 0.90 9.55 0.805 0.642 0.842 -0.806 17.2
S175_L1p050 180 0.95 10.08 0.850 0.678 0.855 -0.808 19.0
S175_L1p050 180 1.00 10.61 0.897 0.716 0.866 -0.810 20.7
S175_L1p050 180 1.05 11.14 0.949 0.757 0.875 -0.811 22.6
S175_L1p050 180 1.10 11.67 0.997 0.795 0.887 -0.813 24.3
S175_L1p100 90 0.90 9.78 0.503 0.401 0.755 -0.784 6.6
S175_L1p100 90 0.95 10.32 0.504 0.403 0.755 -0.784 6.6
S175_L1p100 90 1.00 10.86 0.506 0.404 0.755 -0.784 6.6
S175_L1p100 90 1.05 11.41 0.507 0.405 0.755 -0.784 6.7
S175_L1p100 90 1.10 11.95 0.509 0.406 0.755 -0.784 6.7
S175_L1p100 135 0.90 9.78 0.798 0.637 0.850 -0.808 17.1
S175_L1p100 135 0.95 10.32 0.834 0.665 0.858 -0.809 18.4
S175_L1p100 135 1.00 10.86 0.875 0.698 0.874 -0.811 20.0
S175_L1p100 135 1.05 11.41 0.908 0.724 0.875 -0.811 21.2
S175_L1p100 135 1.10 11.95 0.950 0.758 0.885 -0.812 22.7
S175_L1p100 180 0.90 9.78 0.779 0.621 0.842 -0.806 16.3
S175_L1p100 180 0.95 10.32 0.820 0.655 0.854 -0.808 17.9
S175_L1p100 180 1.00 10.86 0.866 0.691 0.867 -0.810 19.6
S175_L1p100 180 1.05 11.41 0.916 0.731 0.879 -0.812 21.5
S175_L1p100 180 1.10 11.95 0.961 0.767 0.891 -0.813 23.1
DTMB_L0p900 90 0.90 13.16 0.451 0.360 0.810 -0.799 5.6
DTMB_L0p900 90 0.95 13.89 0.451 0.360 0.810 -0.800 5.6
DTMB_L0p900 90 1.00 14.62 0.451 0.360 0.811 -0.800 5.6
DTMB_L0p900 90 1.05 15.35 0.451 0.360 0.811 -0.800 5.6
DTMB_L0p900 90 1.10 16.08 0.451 0.360 0.812 -0.800 5.6
DTMB_L0p900 135 0.90 13.16 0.898 0.717 0.997 -0.819 21.4
DTMB_L0p900 135 0.95 13.89 0.956 0.762 1.013 -0.819 23.4
DTMB_L0p900 135 1.00 14.62 1.012 0.807 1.025 -0.819 25.3
DTMB_L0p900 135 1.05 15.35 1.066 0.851 1.033 -0.819 27.2
DTMB_L0p900 135 1.10 16.08 1.124 0.897 1.046 -0.818 29.1
DTMB_L0p900 180 0.90 13.16 0.954 0.761 1.023 -0.819 23.3
DTMB_L0p900 180 0.95 13.89 1.026 0.819 1.039 -0.818 25.8
DTMB_L0p900 180 1.00 14.62 1.101 0.879 1.056 -0.818 28.3
DTMB_L0p900 180 1.05 15.35 1.197 0.955 1.081 -0.816 31.3
DTMB_L0p900 180 1.10 16.08 1.237 0.987 1.074 -0.817 32.6
DTMB_L0p950 90 0.90 13.52 0.453 0.361 0.815 -0.801 5.7
DTMB_L0p950 90 0.95 14.27 0.453 0.361 0.816 -0.801 5.7
DTMB_L0p950 90 1.00 15.02 0.453 0.361 0.816 -0.801 5.7
DTMB_L0p950 90 1.05 15.77 0.453 0.361 0.817 -0.801 5.7
DTMB_L0p950 90 1.10 16.52 0.453 0.361 0.817 -0.801 5.7
DTMB_L0p950 135 0.90 13.52 0.867 0.692 0.997 -0.819 20.3
DTMB_L0p950 135 0.95 14.27 0.926 0.739 1.015 -0.819 22.4
DTMB_L0p950 135 1.00 15.02 0.982 0.783 1.026 -0.819 24.3
DTMB_L0p950 135 1.05 15.77 1.039 0.829 1.038 -0.818 26.2
DTMB_L0p950 135 1.10 16.52 1.100 0.878 1.054 -0.818 28.2
DTMB_L0p950 180 0.90 13.52 0.904 0.722 1.023 -0.819 21.6
DTMB_L0p950 180 0.95 14.27 0.979 0.781 1.041 -0.818 24.1
DTMB_L0p950 180 1.00 15.02 1.053 0.840 1.058 -0.818 26.6
DTMB_L0p950 180 1.05 15.77 1.156 0.922 1.089 -0.816 29.9
DTMB_L0p950 180 1.10 16.52 1.194 0.953 1.081 -0.816 31.2
DTMB_L1p000 90 0.90 13.87 0.455 0.363 0.821 -0.802 5.8
DTMB_L1p000 90 0.95 14.64 0.455 0.363 0.821 -0.802 5.8
DTMB_L1p000 90 1.00 15.41 0.455 0.363 0.821 -0.802 5.8
DTMB_L1p000 90 1.05 16.18 0.455 0.363 0.822 -0.802 5.8
DTMB_L1p000 90 1.10 16.95 0.455 0.363 0.822 -0.802 5.8
DTMB_L1p000 135 0.90 13.87 0.835 0.666 0.998 -0.819 19.2
DTMB_L1p000 135 0.95 14.64 0.894 0.714 1.017 -0.819 21.2
DTMB_L1p000 135 1.00 15.41 0.949 0.757 1.027 -0.819 23.1
DTMB_L1p000 135 1.05 16.18 1.009 0.805 1.041 -0.818 25.2
DTMB_L1p000 135 1.10 16.95 1.067 0.851 1.054 -0.818 27.1
DTMB_L1p000 180 0.90 13.87 0.855 0.682 1.022 -0.819 19.8
DTMB_L1p000 180 0.95 14.64 0.928 0.740 1.041 -0.818 22.4
DTMB_L1p000 180 1.00 15.41 1.004 0.801 1.060 -0.818 24.9
DTMB_L1p000 180 1.05 16.18 1.111 0.886 1.096 -0.815 28.4
DTMB_L1p000 180 1.10 16.95 1.143 0.912 1.083 -0.816 29.5
DTMB_L1p050 90 0.90 14.21 0.457 0.365 0.826 -0.803 5.9
DTMB_L1p050 90 0.95 15.00 0.457 0.365 0.826 -0.803 5.9
DTMB_L1p050 90 1.00 15.79 0.457 0.365 0.827 -0.803 5.9
DTMB_L1p050 90 1.05 16.58 0.457 0.364 0.827 -0.803 5.9
DTMB_L1p050 90 1.10 17.37 0.457 0.364 0.828 -0.803 5.9
DTMB_L1p050 135 0.90 14.21 0.800 0.638 0.995 -0.819 17.9
DTMB_L1p050 135 0.95 15.00 0.861 0.687 1.017 -0.819 20.1
DTMB_L1p050 135 1.00 15.79 0.918 0.732 1.028 -0.819 22.1
DTMB_L1p050 135 1.05 16.58 0.977 0.780 1.043 -0.818 24.1
DTMB_L1p050 135 1.10 17.37 1.038 0.828 1.057 -0.818 26.1
DTMB_L1p050 180 0.90 14.21 0.808 0.645 1.023 -0.819 18.2
DTMB_L1p050 180 0.95 15.00 0.876 0.699 1.040 -0.818 20.6
DTMB_L1p050 180 1.00 15.79 0.953 0.760 1.061 -0.817 23.2
DTMB_L1p050 180 1.05 16.58 1.065 0.849 1.102 -0.815 26.8
DTMB_L1p050 180 1.10 17.37 1.096 0.874 1.087 -0.816 27.9
DTMB_L1p100 90 0.90 14.55 0.459 0.366 0.831 -0.804 5.9
DTMB_L1p100 90 0.95 15.36 0.459 0.366 0.831 -0.804 5.9
DTMB_L1p100 90 1.00 16.16 0.459 0.366 0.832 -0.804 5.9
DTMB_L1p100 90 1.05 16.97 0.459 0.366 0.832 -0.804 5.9
DTMB_L1p100 90 1.10 17.78 0.459 0.366 0.832 -0.804 5.9
DTMB_L1p100 135 0.90 14.55 0.768 0.613 0.996 -0.819 16.8
DTMB_L1p100 135 0.95 15.36 0.826 0.659 1.015 -0.819 18.8
DTMB_L1p100 135 1.00 16.16 0.885 0.706 1.030 -0.819 20.9
DTMB_L1p100 135 1.05 16.97 0.945 0.754 1.046 -0.818 23.0
DTMB_L1p100 135 1.10 17.78 1.006 0.802 1.060 -0.817 25.0
DTMB_L1p100 180 0.90 14.55 0.755 0.603 1.018 -0.819 16.3
DTMB_L1p100 180 0.95 15.36 0.825 0.658 1.039 -0.818 18.8
DTMB_L1p100 180 1.00 16.16 0.899 0.717 1.060 -0.818 21.3
DTMB_L1p100 180 1.05 16.97 1.009 0.805 1.104 -0.815 24.9
DTMB_L1p100 180 1.10 17.78 1.043 0.833 1.089 -0.816 26.2

12.7 What Changes the MSI

Each section below varies one parameter and keeps the others at the values of the project.

12.7.1 The type of ship

Compare up to five hulls. On the left, their MSI against speed for the headings switched on (solid: head seas, dashed: bow quartering, dotted: beam seas); on the right, their position on the plane of the MSI model at one heading and speed.

Headings against speed:
MSI against speed
The hulls on the plane of the MSI model
Key point

The size of the ship matters more than anything else. In head seas at the design speed, the MSI rises steadily as the ships get smaller: about \(1\%\) for the \(320\) m tanker, \(2\%\) for the \(280\) m bulk carrier, \(9\%\) for the \(230\) m KCS, \(22\%\) for the \(175\) m S175 and \(25\%\) for the \(142\) m combatant. The MSI plane shows the two reasons separately: smaller ships accelerate more, and at frequencies closer to \(1\) rad/s, where people are most susceptible. The large ships move slowly in this long-period sea.

12.7.2 Speed

Key point

Over a \(\pm 10\%\) range of speed, the MSI in head seas grows by \(40\) to \(75\%\) for every hull, while the frequency of the acceleration hardly moves. The acceleration of the cabin is dominated by the heave–pitch resonance of the ship, at a nearly fixed encounter frequency. A faster ship meets that resonance in longer waves, which excite it more strongly (for the KCS, \(\lambda/L_{pp}\) grows from \(1.10\) to \(1.18\)), so \(\bar{a}\) grows. In beam seas \(\omega_e = \omega\), and speed hardly matters.

12.7.3 Heading

Key point

Head seas are not always the worst. For the tanker, the bulk carrier and the KCS, bow quartering seas give a higher MSI, although roll adds almost nothing: oblique waves look \(1/|\cos\beta| \approx 1.4\) times longer along the hull, and excite heave and pitch more strongly. For the smaller S175 and combatant, the two headings are about equal. Beam seas are the mildest; there the acceleration comes from heave, and from roll only where the roll resonance meets the waves.

12.7.4 Length of the hull

Key point

At the same displacement, a longer and slenderer hull is more comfortable in head and bow quartering seas. Heave and pitch resonate in waves of nearly the same length for every variant; for a longer hull these waves are shorter relative to the hull, which spans more of each wave and is excited less. The peaks of the RAOs fall, and so does the head-sea MSI between \(f = 0.90\) and \(1.10\): by about half for the tanker and the bulk carrier, \(40\%\) for the KCS, and \(15\) to \(25\%\) for the S175 and the combatant. In beam seas the narrower hulls heave slightly more.

12.7.5 Position of the cabin

Move the cabin along and across the ship, and watch the phasors of heave, roll and pitch.

Key point

In head and bow quartering seas, the most comfortable place is near midship, where heave and pitch partly cancel: about \(0.12\) to \(0.15\,L_{pp}\) aft of it for the container ships and the combatant, at midship for the tanker and the bulk carrier. A cabin at the bow is much worse: for the KCS in head seas, \(32\%\) instead of \(4\%\). In beam seas the position along the ship hardly matters, but the side may: where roll matters, as for the combatant, a cabin on the weather side (starboard, the side the waves come from) has twice the MSI of one on the lee side.

12.7.6 Roll damping

Key point

The roll damping matters only where the roll resonance meets the waves. The combatant rolls at \(0.54\) rad/s, near the peak of the spectrum, and its beam-sea MSI follows the damping: \(7.6\%\) at \(\zeta_v = 0.025\), \(5.8\%\) at \(0.05\), \(4.8\%\) at \(0.10\). The KCS and the tanker roll below the waves, and the bulk carrier and the S175 on the low-frequency flank of the spectrum, where the factor \(\omega_e^4\) suppresses the acceleration: their MSI hardly changes. Where roll matters, \(\zeta_v\) must be estimated with care, for instance with the method of Ikeda or from a roll decay test.

12.8 Beyond One Sea State: Operability

The project looked at one sea state. Over its life a ship meets all of them, in proportion to the wave scatter diagram (Chapter 11). Since the RAOs do not depend on the sea, the MSI in any other sea state follows from the same calculation with a different spectrum. Repeating it for every cell of the scatter diagram, and adding up the probabilities of the cells in which the MSI stays below a chosen limit, gives the operability of the ship: the percentage of the time for which it meets that comfort criterion.

Key point

A single sea state says how uncomfortable a ship is; the scatter diagram says how often that matters. With a limit of \(20\%\), the tanker and the bulk carrier meet it all the time and the KCS \(99\%\) of the time, in every heading. The S175 and the combatant meet it only \(80\) to \(90\%\) of the time in head and bow quartering seas, so a long-term comfort criterion would push their design, or their operation, towards lower speeds and other headings in rough weather.

The RAOs are known only up to \(1.5\) rad/s, so in the shortest-period sea states, whose spectra extend beyond that, the MSI is somewhat underestimated. Those sea states are low, and their MSI is small.

12.9 Summary

  • The motions: solve the equations of motion from the panel-method coefficients, interpolated onto a fine grid, with a viscous roll damping added; check against HydRA with \(\boldsymbol{B}_v = 0\), and replace the spikes of irregular frequencies.
  • The encounter spectrum \(S^e_{\eta\eta} = S_{\eta\eta}/(1 + 2c\,\omega)\) has the area of the wave spectrum.
  • The cabin moves with the complex sum \(H_P = H_3 + y_P H_4 - x_P H_5\); the cross terms, set by the phases, are as large as the squares. Its acceleration is \(H_a = -\omega_e^2 H_P\), at the encounter frequency.
  • The statistics: \(m_n^a = \int\omega_e^{n+4}|H_P|^2S_{\eta\eta}\,d\omega\), \(\bar{a} = \sqrt{2/\pi}\,\sigma_a\) and \(\bar{\omega}_e = m_1^a/m_0^a\) give the MSI.
  • Operability: repeating the calculation over the wave scatter diagram gives the fraction of the time for which the ship meets a comfort criterion.
  • What changes the MSI: the type and size of the ship most of all; then speed (through the strength of the resonance, not its frequency), heading (bow quartering can be worst), length (longer is better in head and bow seas), the position of the cabin (slightly aft of midship, never at the bow) and, only where roll resonance meets the waves, the roll damping.